The "insanity" defense

Feel free to talk about anything and everything in this board.
Headline back 2
    1,920
    views
    7
    replies
    Last post ago about 7 years by mistye81
    Avatar 31779
    • Started by
      Mighty! Member
      3,046
    • last active about 2 months ago

    Readers of this topic also read:

    Please or register to post or comment.
      • Avatar 31779
        • Started by
          Mighty! Member
          3,046
        • last active about 2 months ago
        Hi Gang:

        In criminal trials, the insanity defenses are possible defenses by excuse.  A affirmative defense by which defendants argue that they should NOT be held criminally liable for breaking the law, as they were legally insane at the time of the commission of alleged crimes.

        A defendant attempting such a defense will often be required to first undergo a mental examination. The legal definition of "insane" in this context is quite different from psychiatric definitions of "mentally ill".

        The insanity defense is based on evaluations by forensic professionals that the defendant was incapable of distinguishing between right and wrong at the time of the offense. In addition, some jurisdictions require that the evaluation address the issue of whether the defendant was able to control his behavior at the time of the offense.

        Now this is where I get confused. Some of the crimes were so awful you say to yourself, "Only someone crazy would of done that. Yet, are they really crazy? Are people abusing the system?

        What are some thoughts from out there on our excellent forum?

                                                                            PMM
      • Avatar 7881
        • Replied by
          Super Hero
          1,492
        • last active 3 months ago
        Okay...great, I get to be a psychologist again!  Yes, some people really can be "insane" thus not guilty by reason of mental illiness or defect. 

        But, many, many mental illnesses might be a hardship, but NOT an excuse for crime.  For example, most cases bi polar disorder. 
      • Putting on lipstick emoticon 1
        • Replied by
          admin
          12,362
        • online
        This is a interesting question....

        If a man goes out and slaughters 15 women......how is that not insane? At least for heinous crimes.

        Or a serial killer who eats body parts and keeps them in jars in his fridge, like Jeffery Dahmer. Lets deliberate over this......was he insane? Hell yeah he was insane.

        Now when it comes to temporary insanity........we are all capable of that. We all have triggers that blow our top at one time or another. What separates us from going off the deep end is self control.

        Do the crime.....pay the time.

        Lips
      • Avatar 7881
        • Replied by
          Super Hero
          1,492
        • last active 3 months ago
        Lips....you make a great point...as usual!  Even if one is "crazy" and commits a crime, that does NOT mean they should not be locked up.
      • Avatar 3763
        • Replied by
          Sr. Member
          289
        • last active 6 months ago
        I have to disagree, what good is throwing a paranoid schizophrenic into lock up.  This is a disease of the mind, most people with this are unaware of just how unrational they are, until they are treated with the right medication, and have the right couseling.  I think that they need to be put in pysch hospital, not prisons. But I don't think that they need to treated and released back into public either, but put into a mental healthcare facility for long term care.  Just my opinion.   
      • Avatar 7881
        • Replied by
          Super Hero
          1,492
        • last active 3 months ago
        If a schizo murders someone, no they should not be put in the regular prison population.  But, we need to invest in quality "mental prisons" for such offenders. 
      • Avatar 3763
        • Replied by
          Sr. Member
          289
        • last active 6 months ago
        Why waste any more money investing in prisons for the mentally ill, when they can be locked up in a psych hospital, its not like they are actually treated much different.  I do however believe that they shouldn't be released back into society.

      lcb activities in the last 24 hours

      • 29
        new members
      • 705
        members online
      • 10129
        guests online
      • 107
        new posts
      • 7147
        free games played
      Join the club

      Most viewed forum posts

      • Putting on lipstick emoticon 1
        Hi LCB'ers! Got a great costume ready for this weekend? We thought it would be fun to run a short contest and hand out some LCB candy of our  own. Halloween is near and we want to see what our members are wearing to...
        Closed - LCB Halloween Costume Contest
      • Index
        Mr Green’s €350K Christmas Calendar Christmas has come earlier at Mr Green, therefore, thay have prepared enjoyable daily giveaways. You are invited to join an adventure tour through Mr Green's festive Wonderland...
        Christmas 2016 advent calendars, goodies and bonuses
      • Putting on lipstick emoticon 1
        LCB $500 10th Anniversary Contest Wow, can you even believe it’s been a whole ten years we have been around! I know I am personally thrilled I have shared this time together with the old timers and of course all...
        Closed - LCB $500 10th Anniversary Contest

      Join today and start earning rewards

      You will immediately get full access to our online casino forum/chat plus receive our newsletter with news & exclusive bonuses every month.
      S logo
      Select Language
      Search
      Search Results

      Report to moderator

      Use this function to inform the moderators and administrator of an abusive or wrongly posted message.

      Please note that your email address will be revealed to the moderators if you use this

      Submit
      39012170